Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare: Addressing Ethical and Regulatory Hurdles

Feb 12, 2024
Life Sciences | 7 min READ
What started as a chat-based assistant has now evolved into a significant improvement in how content is generated with virtual assistants and image recognition systems. Integrating artificial intelligence in healthcare has been transformative, impacting everything from detection methods to enhancing cures. However, as this collaboration progresses, it is crucial to understand, govern, and administer the limitations and capabilities of AI-driven systems.
John Danese
John Danese

Associate Vice President, Life Sciences & Healthcare


Nitin Jindal
Nitin Jindal

Global Digital Partner


Achieving a delicate equilibrium among inventive concepts, ensuring the well-being of patients, and maintaining the confidentiality of their data is essential to fully harnessing the capabilities of artificial intelligence in the healthcare sector.
AI is trained to find the best ways to treat patients, understand healthcare trends, and improve healthcare delivery, offering improved patient outcomes. But where do we set limits, or how do we strike the right balance between innovation, responsibility, and ethics?
Stay Ahead
Visit our Life Sciences & Healthcare page
Regulatory Landscape in AI-Driven Healthcare
The current challenge lies in the abstract nature of AI concepts. AI systems must become more transparent, specific, and reliably accurate to realize the tangible effects mentioned earlier. Legislative efforts, such as adopting the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and discussions on AI regulatory frameworks, aim to address information imbalances. While these laws emphasize transparency, they lack a precise definition and primarily focus on specific actions, especially concerning data, intellectual property (IP) rights, and privacy.
The FDA demands that medical device manufacturers maintain a quality system for manufacturing their products. This system should be dedicated to creating, delivering, and sustaining consistent quality products that function according to their documented specifications and according to their relevant regulations throughout their lifecycle. This emphasis on quality must also ensure that healthcare technology, such as Generative AI, used in clinical settings, meets the necessary safety and effectiveness benchmarks.
Alongside legal efforts, groups like the European Commission, ENISA, and DARPA work on ethical AI standards, with criteria including promoting cyber-hygiene, reducing third-party dependency, and encouraging global harmonization. All these initiatives shape the complex world of AI regulations, aiming for clarity, quality, and ethics in healthcare.
However, the ever-changing tech landscape brings new challenges, requiring constant adjustments, especially in making different AI systems in healthcare collaborate seamlessly. This ongoing challenge demands industry-wide collaboration to ensure varied systems can effectively mitigate real-time risk.
Ethical Considerations in AI-Driven Healthcare
For AI systems to be more ethical, they must be trained on a reliably accurate data foundation to base decisions on continuous collection, generation, and verification of data, information, and knowledge. This emphasizes the need for transparency in AI algorithms, ensuring clarity in the decision-making process for patients and healthcare providers.
The accuracy of AI outcomes relies on the quality and relevance of inputs. Therefore, establishing procedures for controlling and validating data during training is crucial. Simultaneously, mechanisms must be developed to assess specific outputs in real-life AI system use. This assessment goes beyond explanations; it involves keeping records of AI development and testing, tracing each step, and implementing data governance and management procedures.
In ethical AI-enhanced healthcare, efforts must be made to correct algorithm biases to promote fairness and inclusivity. The focus is empowering providers and patients, safeguarding their information, and striving for fairness in AI technology applications. Shared decision-making with AI tools requires healthcare professionals to have the tools for informed choices. Patients should access comprehensive information about their health, including conditions, risks, treatment outcomes, costs, and alternatives, ensuring complete comprehension for active participation in health decisions. Ethical considerations align technology with principles, benefiting patients and advancing healthcare quality and accessibility.
Striking a Balance: Innovation vs. Regulation
Establishing a robust regulatory framework for AI is essential for effectively implementing and enforcing emerging technologies. A detailed and practical understanding of high-level concepts must be highlighted to achieve this, outlining specific requirements for systems and individuals involved. Organizations must provide information about the use of AI, its intended purpose(s), the types of data sets utilized, and meaningful details about the logic involved and its testing. A future AI framework, particularly in healthcare legislation, should adopt an approach that minimizes risks while considering relevant benefits. This approach, already present in healthcare legislation, acknowledges the necessity of accepting some risks weighed against the potential benefits.
Regulators must oversee AI systems and be able to identify missing elements in the input and output, recognizing potential legal, discriminatory, or ethical gaps. They should be well-versed in IoT-connected privacy, transparency, and security issues relevant to the specific application of the AI system. Since AI systems span diverse scientific realms like biology, engineering, and medicine, domain-specific expertise is imperative for inspectors.
Ethical guidelines for AI developers should include transparency provisions, ensuring AI systems disclose their decision-making data sources and processes. Ethical considerations must extend to addressing biases in AI algorithms, emphasizing fairness, and actively working to eliminate discriminatory outcomes.
Privacy protection should be a fundamental element, requiring developers to prioritize user data security and obtain informed consent for third-party data usage of intellectual property. Developers should also reflect upon the possible social impact of their AI systems, striving to minimize negative consequences and promote positive contributions to society.
Incorporating ethical considerations into the AI development cycle entails thorough testing for biases, uninterrupted monitoring for potential ethical concerns, and establishing mechanisms to address issues that may arise during the system's lifecycle. An ethical code of conduct should encourage developers to engage in ongoing education and awareness about emerging ethical challenges in AI. It should foster collaborative efforts within the industry to share best practices and collectively address ethical limitations.
Future Vision
The AI genie is clearly out of the bottle, and its use in healthcare will continue to evolve rapidly, becoming more reliable and enabling precision medicine, empowering patients, and enabling more efficient healthcare practices, hopefully contributing to lower cost and equitable healthcare. This shift will move healthcare from a one-size-fits-all approach to a personalized, data-driven model focused on prevention and improved disease management. This transformation aims to enhance patient outcomes, clinical experiences, and cost-effectiveness.
AI's potential impact includes reducing inefficiencies in healthcare, improving patient flow, and enhancing caregiver and patient safety. AI can play a role in remote patient monitoring, using wearables and sensors for intelligent telehealth, and identifying and promptly addressing risks.
Studies have shown that AI can match or surpass human experts in image-based diagnoses across various medical specialties. This advancement will improve clinical trial design, drug manufacturing processes, and the overall optimization of healthcare processes through AI-driven solutions.
Recommendations for Stakeholders
A critical need exists to deepen our understanding of diseases to advance precision therapeutics. Stakeholders can contribute through endorsing research initiatives, promoting data-sharing platforms, and fostering cross-disciplinary collaborations.
Transparency ensures that unbiased data is used and that the outcomes are fair. AI algorithms often operate independently, lacking openness in decision-making. To ensure fairness, stakeholders must define transparency comprehensively, as AI systems cover broader operational aspects. In contrast, openness for algorithms focuses on the specific processes and decision-making mechanisms that shape the system's functionality.
Trust-building in AI requires a comprehensive approach, acknowledging that explainability is just one facet. Encourage a multifaceted strategy, incorporating technical, procedural, and educational tools for ensuring fairness and robustness in AI systems.
Legislative enforcement should empower users to comprehend and challenge AI decisions impacting their fundamental rights. Ensuring proactive disclosure of AI interactions and additional information about sources when fundamental rights are jeopardized enhances user understanding and trust. Transparency requirements should effectively protect sensitive (IP) and personal information, emphasizing the need for balanced post-deployment transparency.
Ensuring the discoverability of AI systems is pivotal. Disclosure requirements should make interactions easily discernible, utilizing plain and unambiguous language for user comprehension. Disclosures should remain flexible and placed under the responsibility of the AI system deployers.
Artificial Intelligence in healthcare stands to reshape it, promising advancements in personalization, precision, predictability, and efficiency. However, the journey to establish accountability in AI is marked by challenges, including the need for a more precise definition and the inherent complexity of AI systems.
Adequate data and AI governance hinge on a well-balanced mix of human-enabled policy, process, and artificial cognitive technologies, emphasizing contemporary data architecture and reliable AI platforms. Policy orchestration within a data fabric architecture simplifies intricate AI audit processes. Incorporating AI ethics and guidelines into governance policies empowers organizations to continually scrutinize and improve their practices.
Embracing standardization is crucial to fostering ethically designed AI, aiding government and corporate oversight through business, legal, and technology experts and authorities. As we navigate the complexities of this evolving field, the emphasis must remain on cultivating an ethical AI framework that prioritizes patient empowerment, inclusivity, and fairness, ushering in a new era where advanced technology aligns seamlessly with the fundamental principles of compassionate and responsible healthcare.
Was this article helpful?
More from this Author
 Transforming Life Sciences Future
Generative AI Breakthroughs: Transforming Life Sciences Future
Life Sciences | 2 min Read
How Generative AI is Reshaping Every Link in the Life Sciences Value Chain
How Generative AI is Reshaping Every Link in the Life Sciences Value Chain
Life Sciences | 5 min Read
India is Becoming Self-Reliant in Healthcare with AI, IoT
Automation in Pharmacovigilance:India is Becoming Self-Reliant in Healthcare with AI, IoT
Life Sciences | 5 min Read